Most of us were never taught what a healthy boundary feels like. So when we finally try to set one with family, it often comes out as something else. Sometimes we build a wall and pull away completely, because staying feels unbearable. Sometimes we issue an ultimatum and demand that the other person change or else. Other times, we let the boundary slip the moment someone pushes back, and we tell ourselves it wasn't that important anyway.

Each time, we end up feeling worse than before. When we build a wall, we feel relieved at first, and then lonely in a way we can't quite explain. When we issue an ultimatum, we feel guilty for hurting someone we love, and afraid that we have broken something between us. And when we cave, we feel heavy and small, as if we have disappeared again, and we ask ourselves a question we have asked many times before: "Why is it so hard to ask for something this small?"

If you have felt any of this, please know how much sense it makes. In the last essay, we looked at the roles we were handed and how we learned, as children, to leave ourselves so we could stay close to the people we needed. When we set a boundary, we try to do the opposite: we stay with ourselves while staying in the relationship. For many of us, it is the first time we have tried, and our bodies have no practice with it. I have seen this in individuals, couples, and my own family, and I know how frightening that first attempt can feel.

Three Things That Look Alike

A boundary, a wall, and an ultimatum can sound similar when we say them out loud. We reach for each one from a different place inside us, and the people we love feel each one differently.

Imagine a parent who calls several times a day while you are working, and gets upset when you don't answer. If you build a wall, you go silent: you stop picking up altogether, sometimes for days, because you dread every call and can't find another way to protect yourself. If you issue an ultimatum, you say something like, "If you keep calling me at work, I'm going to stop talking to you." If you set a boundary, you say, "I don't take personal calls during my workday. I'll call you back after six, and I'd love to hear how your day went."

We build walls when we feel overwhelmed and see no other way to keep ourselves safe.

We feel relieved when the calls stop, and over time we often feel lonely, because the people we pulled away from can no longer know us. We issue ultimatums when we feel exhausted and frightened, often after years of asking and feeling unheard, until part of us stops believing that asking will ever work. We set boundaries when we can stay connected to the other person and still say clearly what we will do.

Setting a boundary is both kind and hard. We ask nothing of the other person except that they live with our choice, and we ask a great deal of ourselves: to make the choice, say it plainly, and keep making it.

When Boundary Language Becomes Control

Maybe you have heard yourself say it in the middle of an argument, "You're violating my boundary," and watched your mother's face close. Many of us learned the language of boundaries from therapy, social media, and books, and that language has helped many people speak up for themselves. In a painful moment, though, we can end up using it to ask someone else to change.

When we say "You're violating my boundary" or "You need to respect my boundaries" in the heat of a conflict, we are often asking the other person to change their behavior so we can feel safe. That is a request, and we are allowed to make requests.

When we call it a boundary, though, we turn it into a rule we expect them to follow; and when they don't, we feel betrayed, and they feel controlled.

A boundary describes what we will do. "I'm going to leave the conversation if the shouting continues" is a boundary. "You are not allowed to raise your voice at me" is a rule for someone else, however reasonable it is. Only one of them is in our power to keep.

If you have used boundary language this way, please be gentle with yourself. Most of us reach for it when we feel hurt and frightened and want the hurting to stop. When we notice it with kindness, we start learning to hold a boundary from a steadier place.

When Family Comes First

In many communal cultures, including Iranian families like mine and many other immigrant and collectivist families, when we set a personal boundary, our families often hear it as a rejection of the family itself, or call us selfish. Many of us were raised to believe that tending to ourselves comes second to tending to family and community. So even when we set a small, healthy boundary, we can feel as if we are betraying the people around us, and the child in us who learned those lessons feels it too.

It makes sense that so many of us feel resentful in families like these, often without anyone meaning it to happen. From the outside, our families may look close and devoted. From the inside, many of us feel that the closeness costs us ourselves. Instead of feeling nurtured and supported, we feel we have to perform, appease, and abandon ourselves to belong. And I would argue the collective pays a price too. When we don't feel safe being ourselves, we stop showing who we are, and we lose the emotional connection, depth, and vulnerability we could have with each other.

We can sit at the same table for years and still feel lonely, because no one has been allowed to see who we are.

I know this from my own family. I know how painful it is to be seen as selfish in the same moment you are trying to take care of yourself, so that you can keep showing up for the people you love with an open heart instead of resentment.

If you come from a family like this, please know that wanting a boundary is a sign of health, and that your family's reaction makes sense too. They learned the same lessons you did. When you hold your ground with love, without hardening into a wall, you offer them something generous: you show them that closeness and selfhood can exist in the same family.

Why Holding a Boundary Is Harder Than Setting It

Sometimes our family accepts the boundary at first. Your mother says, "Of course, I understand." You feel lighter, even a little hopeful. Then you practice the boundary, and she starts pushing back. You don't answer during work, and she calls three times. She always finds a new reason why this particular situation should be an exception: a cousin's news, a question that couldn't wait, a feeling that you have changed.

Some exceptions are real, like a hospital visit or a death in the family, and you are the one who decides what counts as one, no one else.

To hold a boundary under that kind of pressure, we need tremendous resilience, clarity, and persistence. When the accusations come, "You've become so selfish," "You don't care about us anymore," we feel as if our belonging is under threat, because our nervous systems learned long ago that losing a parent's approval was dangerous. We feel the fear, obligation, and guilt we explored in the first essay all at once. Your chest tightens, your face gets hot, and you want the conflict to end more than anything. You know the fastest way to end it is to give in.

That is why so many of us cave. In the short term, it is almost always easier to give in and abandon ourselves than to keep having the same argument, over and over, with people we love.

Most of us are facing a capacity problem more than a knowledge problem.

We know what we need and what we want to say. Consciously or subconsciously, we would rather give in than face a conflict, disappoint someone we love, or feel the discomfort of not stepping in as the rescuer we have always been. When we give in, we feel relieved right away, and of course we reach for that relief. We try to protect our connection to the people who matter to us.

I work with people who hold firm limits with colleagues, clients, and even partners, yet still let their boundaries and needs erode with a parent, little by little, because giving in feels less costly than another conflict. What they are building, and what all of us are building, is the capacity to stay with the discomfort, the judgment, the guilt, and the tension a little longer each time, and to choose to hold firm anyway.

Holding a Boundary Through Pushback

Sometimes our families do come around. After months of pushback, a parent starts texting instead of calling during the day, or a sibling stops raising the subject you asked them to leave alone. When we look back at those moments, we usually find a few things in common.

Picture one of them. You said it on a calm Sunday afternoon instead of in the middle of an argument, because when your heart is pounding and your voice is rising, the other person hears your alarm more than your words. You said it with warmth: "I'll call you back after six, and I'd love to hear how your day went."

Many people resist a boundary because they feel rejected by it, and when you add warmth, they can hear that you still want them in your life.

The fifth and the tenth time, you said it the same way as the first, with no new threats, no long defense, and no apology: "I know, and I'll call you after six." Slowly, the people around you learned that the boundary was real, and your love was real too. And you left room for their feelings. Your mother could feel disappointed, sad, or even angry, and you could still keep the boundary. You didn't have to fix her feelings or argue her out of them. You could say, "I understand this is hard for you," and keep your choice.

Before a conversation you are dreading, you can prepare your body as well as your words. Slow your breathing, letting each exhale last longer than the inhale, and feel your feet on the floor. If a call or visit becomes too much, excuse yourself for a few minutes, splash cold water on your face, or step outside for a short walk. Each of these helps your nervous system regulate, so you can return to the conversation as yourself instead of caving or hardening. And as we saw in the first essay, you never have to answer a request in the moment. When you take time before you respond, you are setting a boundary too.

Holding boundaries with family is a skill you build through practice, each time you feel the familiar pressure rise and stay with it a little longer than the time before. These patterns are old, and many of us need support from a therapist or coach to build this capacity. Most of us find it far easier to keep going with someone beside us while we practice. If you would like help with this, you can reach out to me.

This is your sovereignty of choice. You can't control whether your family agrees with your boundary, how they react to it, or how many times they test it. You can decide, each time, whether to keep it. That decision belongs to you, and no one can make it for you.

If a relationship involves abuse, violence, or real danger, building a wall may be the healthiest and most loving choice you can make for yourself. Sometimes distance protects you, and you are the one who knows when that is true.

I'd like to think of this as learning to stay in the room with the people we love while keeping a door that is ours to open and close. In the next essay, we'll look at how to keep an open heart and a strong boundary at the same time, without having to choose between connection and ourselves. Until then, choose one boundary that matters to you, say it with warmth, and keep it with care.

‍

Essays on Capacity, Presence, and Relationships
Welcome aboard! Please check your email to confirm your subscription.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form. Please try again.